Saturday, May 12, 2018

21 Finally I Lost a Plane


“After all, we were a bunch of kids just having a ball, fighting a war.”
—Major General James B. Tipton, 1985[1]

 
Lt. Killingsworth

Lt. Huff

Risk-Taking between the Earth and Sky
Filled with exuberance and youthful enthusiasm and sure they were immortal, the P-51 pilots flew high over the earth faster than ever imaginable on the ground. They savored the thrill and the adrenaline rush of entering into combat with enemy planes.

Pilots of the 380th relaxing together
The German pilots were just as anxious to knock them out of the sky. Sometimes they were successful. That spring of 1944 the 380th Squadron sent up their P-51s on bomber escort missions and then on dive-bombing and armed reconnaissance missions. Their gutsy pilots had successful encounters with Messerschmitts, Focke-Wulfs, and Junkers, destroying or damaging them in the air. They also hit locomotives, barges, and radio and flak towers, dive-bombing ground targets to cripple the Nazi offense in any way possible.[2]

Waiting: On the Ground
From Jack’s perspective on the ground: After a mission it was always exciting to see the planes come in four at a time, peel off, and land. This thrilling video shows what Jack saw daily, P-51s taking off, flying in formation, and peeling off for landing. 
Ground crew members waiting

The pilots were at the mercy of the weather, the mechanical capabilities of their planes, Luftwaffe fighters, and flak from the ground. Not all returned. In March the 380th Squadron’s roster included four flights of eight or nine pilots each. In three months, it lost ten pilots and their planes.[3] Some of the pilots parachuted to safety. Some were taken prisoner. Some were killed. The ground crews didn’t always know what happened to them.

8 April: Lt. Alfred Fontes disappeared near Brunswick [Braunschweig], Germany, on a bomber support run.[4]
11 April: 2nd Lt. James B. McKenna, piloting one of two radio relay planes, “developed engine trouble and was last seen by his wing man when they entered the overcast while over the channel on their return to base.”[5]
22 April: Lt. Paul R. Maxwell was hit by flak and parachuted to safety near Speyer.[6]
23 April: Lt. James E. Barlow encountered heavy flak over Ooterwalde [Osterholz?] Airfield and was believed to bail out safely.[7]
11 May: Lts. Roy Benson and Lloyd M. Bruce were attacked by ME-109s in the Marche area and may have bailed out.[8]
28 May: Lt. Feodor Clemovitz was shot down by ME-109s west of Gardelegen, Germany.[9]
11 June: 1st Lt. Edwin E. Vance was hit by flak and crashed near Carentan on the Cherbourg peninsula after successfully targeting a bridge at Sainte-Suzanne-sur-Vire and railway repair shops at Gourfalant [Gourfaleur], France.[10]
17 June: 1st Lt. Herbert F. Lyman scored hits on a truck concentration and then was hit by flak and crashed near Savigny, France.[11]
19 June: 1st Lt. Ernest L. Nicholas’ plane was damaged by flak over Calais. Another P-51 escorted him to a point in the Channel near Cap Nez-Gris, where he had to bail out. Rescue boats were unable to find him.[12]
 
A P-51 formation as seen from the ground
Finally I Lost a Plane
Captain McCall had flown his missions, and I had a fairly new replacement pilot, a young second lieutenant pilot. One day after a strafing mission to France my plane did not come back. When you hear the planes coming back, you’re always looking for your formation. Mine was A9B, which means that it would be in the first formation; usually it would be the end. We’d watch as they peeled off, and you could tell whose planes were coming back. Well, there was no 19 9B in that flight that day. My plane was missing.

Did I do something wrong? I immediately contacted the pilots in his flight who were flying his wing. They said German artillery was firing at our planes, and he had gone down to strafe a German flak tower. They could see the tracer bullets going into my plane and pilot and not coming out. He never pulled up at all, so he must have been killed immediately. I had tears in my eyes.[13]

From another pilot's perspective

Jack didn't mention his pilot’s name. None of his surviving letters to Alice mentions a pilot by name. He may not have known him well enough to remember. Three who were killed that spring were Jack’s age (twenty-two) and younger: Lts. McKenna, Vance, and Nicholas. 2nd Lt. McKenna was most likely Jack’s pilot. He was born in England in 1921, a couple weeks before Jack. His family emigrated to the U.S. when he was a toddler and settled in Miami, Florida. An ironic twist of fate places his memorial plaque in the Cambridge American Cemetery and Memorial, Cambridge, England, returning his memory to the country of his birth.[14]

Tablets of the Missing entry for James B. McKenna
Courtesy of Geoffrey Gillon, photographer[15]

Waiting: At Home

Vera (Lewis) Nicholas and her son Ernest
Courtesy of Karie Nicholas
[16]   
John L. Nicholas receiving the Purple
Heart on behalf of his son Ernest
Courtesy of Karie Nicholas
[17]





















Opportunity
So I was without a plane. While I was waiting for a new plane, I was given the job to crew the small C[essna]-78 two-engine [five-seater] transport plane that we had. I made a lot of flights with the pilot, transporting people back and forth to different places. I traveled around quite a bit. Sometimes we would go where one of our planes had landed after being shot up or out of gas and just able to reach England, but not our base. They took me there in the C-78, and I would get the aircraft going again so it could be flown back to our base.

C-78[18]


One time I got into the C-78 with some pilots and a couple of us crew chiefs, and we went down to Land’s End, way down in Plymouth in southern England. We had planes downed down there, and we worked on them until we could get them fixed up good enough to get them home. So I crewed that C-78 for a while, and that was fun.[19]

The ground crews had to steel themselves for the possibility that their pilots would not return. Working hard gave them the focus necessary to keep their emotions in check. Sometimes, as in Jack’s case, that hard work was also fun. Decades later he could still recall the detailed work that was his part of the D-Day effort.



[1] Judd A. Katz, U. S. Air Force Oral History Interview of Major General James B. Tipton, July 15, 1985, Auburn University, Montgomery, Alabama; digital images, The University of Alabama Libraries Digital Collections, James Tipton papers (http://purl.lib.ua.edu/122063 : accessed 19 March 2018), 35.
[2] 380th Fighter–160th Tac. Rcn. Squadron History, February 1943–August 1945 ([unknown place]: [unknown publisher], printed by A. Roßbach, Eschwege, Germany [1945]), 33.
[3] 380th Fighter–160th Tac. Rcn. Squadron History, 14, 20, 25.
[4] Nick Marinelli, The History of the 363rd Fighter Group, 380th Fighter Squadron, 381st Fighter Squadron, 382nd Fighter Squadron, 9th Air Force, ETO, IX Tactical Air Command, 70th Fighter Wing until August 1, 1944, XIX Tactical Air Command, 100th Fighter Wing until August 29, 1944, Reorganized as the 363rd Tactical Reconnaissance Group, 160th Tactical Reconnaissance Squadron, 161st Tactical Reconnaissance Squadron, 162nd Tactical Reconnaissance Squadron after September 4, 1944, and attached to the XXIX Tactical Air Command (South Lynn, Mich.: Nick Marinelli, 1992), 4–45. Also, 380th Fighter–160th Tac. Rcn. Squadron History, 20, 21. Also, Kent D. Miller, Seven Months Over Europe: The 363rd Fighter Group in World War Two (Hicksville, Ohio: Kent D. Miller, 1989), 9-10.
[5] 380th Fighter–160th Tac. Rcn. Squadron History, 22. Also, Marinelli, History, 4–47, 4–48.
[6] 380th Fighter–160th Tac. Rcn. Squadron History, 23. Also, Miller, Seven Months, 13. Also, Marinelli, History, 4–53.
[7] 380th Fighter–160th Tac. Rcn. Squadron History, 23. Also, Marinelli, History, 4-56.
[8] 380th Fighter–160th Tac. Rcn. Squadron History, 24, 25. Also, Miller, Seven Months, 17.
[9] Miller, Seven Months, 19.
[10] 380th Fighter–160th Tac. Rcn. Squadron History, 33–34.
[11] 380th Fighter–160th Tac. Rcn. Squadron History, 35. Also Miller, Seven Months, 25.
[12] 380th Fighter–160th Tac. Rcn. Squadron History, 35. Also, Miller, Seven Months, 27.
[13] Jack J. Kellar, “Autobiography,” 1998; two ninety-minute cassette tape recordings; held and partially transcribed by the author.
[14] EKRINGC, owner, “Ellie Schoppe Family Tree,” Ancestry (http://trees.ancestry.com/tree/33809727 : accessed 3 February 2017), James B. McKenna. Also, “2Lt James B McKenna,” Find A Grave (https://www.findagrave.com/memorial/56292337/james-b-mckenna : accessed 10 May 2018), Memorial no. 56292337.
[15] darealjolo, “Tablets of the Missing, detail, photographer, Find A Grave (https://images.findagrave.com/photos/2015/33/56292337_1423009357.jpg : accessed 10 May 2018), Memorial no. 56292337, James B McKenna.
[16] kjnicholas, owner, “Nicholas-Lewis,” family tree, Ancestry (https://www.ancestry.com/family-tree/person/tree/7053735/person/1482546948/gallery : accessed 11 May 2018), gallery for Ernest Nicholas.
[17] Ibid.
[18] Cessna UC-78 “Bobcat,” photograph, Wikimedia Commons (https://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:Cessna_UC-78_Bobcat_in_flight.jpg : accessed 10 May 2018), a public domain image created by a U.S. Army soldier or employee as part of official duties.
[19] Jack J. Kellar, “Autobiography,” 1998.

2 comments: